Consignment

How consignment works

1. You send us a list of items you want to consign (singles $50+, sealed product, vintage MTG, sealed boxes, anything where the buylist-vs-market gap is wide).
2. We agree on a list price for each item and a consignment percentage (typically 80–90% of the final sale to you, with the remainder being our handling and listing cost).
3. You ship the items to us — we provide a prepaid label for consignments over $250 in agreed list price.
4. We list across our site, TCGPlayer, and eBay. Items stay listed for up to 90 days at the agreed price.
5. When something sells, you get paid within 7 days of the order shipping (we pay after the buyer's return window closes).

What's a good consignment candidate

• Reserved List MTG — Power 9, dual lands, older mythics with limited supply.
• Graded slabs (PSA, BGS, CGC) — Pokémon, Magic, sports-style grading.
• Sealed vintage product — old booster boxes, factory-sealed decks.
• Modern format staples in volume — playsets and 10+ playsets of cards moving up.
• Anything where the buylist offer feels punitively low. If a buylist quote feels like 50% of what it could fetch, consignment usually closes that gap.

What we don't consign

• Bulk commons and uncommons (just sell to buylist).
• Heavily played cards under $20 (the listing overhead doesn't earn out).
• Counterfeits, alters, or anything that fails authentication on arrival.

What we handle

• Photography, condition grading, and listing copy.
• Listing across our site, TCGPlayer, and eBay simultaneously.
• Payment processing, packing, shipping, and customer questions.
• Returns and chargebacks (we eat the risk on disputes that aren't your fault).

Start a consignment

Email info@etcetera.games with a list of what you'd like to consign — names, sets, condition, and your target price (if you have one). We'll respond within one business day with terms.